Betrayal by James Charles

1 Like

Not to be rude, but why are your songs so repetitive?

They are not too repetitive. I compose them in different verses and sequences. Also why would I create 4 or 5 different sequences. It loses the song style, so that’s how a song should usually be . Music is music. Just be glad you enjoy it.

Also the song Rhubarb is beyond repetitive.

That one was actually a cover of a classic ambient track.

Regardless, try not to respond to criticism like that. Trust me, just saying that that is the song’s “style” will not help you in the long run (I tried to do that in my first couple years). Just accept it, make a mental note of it, think of ways to improve your next composition. Your piece is not bad at all. I find it very cool, and I can tell you put work and detail into it.

i never said it was bad, i just said it was repetitive, thats all. This is quite good, im just saying.

I know I know. I’m glad you like the song, but I wasn’t trying to get mad or anything, I was just saying it’s not completely repetitive. So if you thought I was mad, I’m not and I’ve heard plenty of constructive criticism and I give that kind of criticism myself. So I’m kinda used to it, just so you know.