QVX 797's Song Thread <<NEW: Home Stretch>>

Well fuck.

…Is there some sort of conspiracy theory I don’t know about? We mess with each other, but I don’t see any hating unless if something unnerving is said.

You obviously haven’t seen ix’s longest post.

Also QVX … ix’s method is a bit mathematical … I would suggest just listening to music a lot, playing an instrument would help, singing would help (even just humming scales), whenever a tune comes to head keep repeating it, and a brief look at guidelines from theory. The melodies in Golden Sands and the unfinished song cough just came naturally to me, maybe because I’ve been playing/learning music from a young age, or that’s just who I am … but theory might suit you … I don’t know just try different things.

I don’t not like you ix, we argue a lot but arguing is fun

No you sir are the angry one here, good day. storms off to edit his massive post so it can become the ULTRA POST OF DEATH and DESTROY all ENEMIES!

Karo, when i posted that comment, it was the 26th here.

It’s funny cause i do all of those things

Sadly…that took a while for me to get.

Well, also since i am going on exchange next year, it would be better for me to at least have a… relatively large break (half a year) and that should also give me time to be inspired and…well learn more about melodies
I am yet to decide how active i’ll be in the forums though while i am not composing however people.posted

I don’t think there’s a single person here that doesn’t do all of those (minus singing)

2 things,

  1. No matter who tries to help it seems i just can’t pick it up
    although there is one member who is helping me right now and i am slowly getting the basics…i could say who but that would give away who one of my collabs are with
    In case no-one knows, i wasn’t taught ANY music AT ALL, so i don’t know what a major/minor key is, i don’t know how to…do anything that involves constructing a tune or melody…and whenever i keep searching for things, it always assumes that you know what arpeggios and diminished notes and are etc…gawd i feel stupid -.-…

  2. New song…
    Its like a new…adventure RPG kinda thing…
    Note: QVX 797 was definitely high when composing this…ugh…song…you have been warned…
    Endless (Part 1)

Its the same with me,I don’t really know how to make a melody I just mess around on my keyboard until something comes up.
So this is my first attempt at trying to make an original song.Its some of kind short theme

I am sorry for putting for putting this in your thread QVX(I forgot that this was your thread)

Get a book or something … I have a few great music books.

That was good! A little repetitive though, but still it was good.

That was also good! You should try to make it longer.

I think what you have a problem with mainly is using the same note length, OVER AND OVER.
If you change that up, and experiment with different note lengths.
Thats what I do, I experiment until i find something cool, use it, and then if it gets to where i don’t like it, scrap it!

To succeed you first must fail, and you must fail, many, many, MANY times.

There is my other 2 cents

^That was my problem with the song. Lack of note lengths and lots of repetitiveness.
You can have something completely new on a verse, start from scratch, don’t just keep on copy and pasting.
The difference between your songs and the good songs, is they have a change, or even are constantly changing.

Also I wasn’t taught any of this, and I haven’t even looked at anything really. I just listen to other good songs, and experiment with things that have been done.
I didn’t know what an arpeggio was, and I knew there was major and minor keys, but I didn’t know what the heck they were
If you were to find one of my earlier songs, like the “damant journey” part… ya you could tell

I hope you take this heart and use it to make you better!

Then it would be extremely repetative, lol, part 2 will be a cave like theme…and maybe the last part will be like the first…only revisited.
Oh, and thats ok, besides it sounded awesome…totally worth listening to (you have to finish it XD)

I will definitely keep that in mind, thank you

Well a music shop would have them … but so would a bookshop or library or even you could order one online or just download a free one.
But just continue getting help from that person who’s helping you … getting taught is the best way. (It’s ix, isn’t it?)

Just try new patterns or anything for your song … experimentation.

First things first, good song.

Now, I wasn’t taught keys either; but just wondering how old are you?
I learned all I know about music at Advanced & Jazz band. [In 7th grade as of now.]

What I did was learn it slowly. You skipped the stage to know the three basic major/minor keys. [IMO the first three keys in major and minor respectively.] But never mind that as I did the same, so I was at the point to making melodies and such. First I learned keys, then arpeggios, then note lengths, and then random music stuff after.

Don’t complicate melodies, riffs, and arpeggios, diminished, etc…
It really is just what makes up the song. Use analogies or lists if you need to.
Ex.) Basic Song: Intro > Chorus > Verse > Chorus[2] > Verse[2] > Chorus[3] > End (The [#] shows a different rendition.)

Just make melodies, beats, and riffs and your set. You need to arrange and edit them in the form of choruses, verses, etc…

Oh, and if creativity is a low, make the riff or melody slightly different.
Ex.) Carol of the Bells: 1.] Bb, A, Bb, G | 2.] G, F#, G, E

Intros can be one or more instrument playing, it should show the beginning mood.
Endings can be also one or more instruments playing but it should be the climax or the remake of an intro.

Also, I’ll work on our collab tomorrow, busy with school. [High School course in 7th grade? Gasp.]
:3

Well i guess that makes me older than you…i’m 15 <.<
Theres not really much to offer (music-related) around where i live…

Yeah it is the best way.
See ix is also but he is starting too complex :3…
it starts with S and they’re not a moderator

Scourge?

Well that ruined my fun
XD

So…umm…i’m trying something new…and making a much more in depth song…
Technicality
Maybe you could be able to add or apply an example to the song to help me understand some things better…or just provide feedback with or without relation to what i have recently been told about.

It kinda sounds like a song Karo would make XD

Well firstly, about the first melody, the Db is a little obtrusive, it doesn’t really fit in (be careful not to make the melodies too complicated by adding in accidentals (notes that aren’t from the scale)).
It was a great melody though. Also instead of having the original melody (x2) and then changing it a bit (x2), you could have just had the original, then the changed, then the original, then the changed. Confusing?
Also sorry to say but measures 4+5 did not work at all. What scale are you using? All I can see are Db’s which don’t belong to any scale on their own.

I liked the bit at the end, too, that was good.

I originally had sheets 2 and 3 in there…so it was a build up…it dragged on too long though so i took 2 and 3 out…
With the original, changed, original, changed thing it didn’t really work…
Also the Db at the start…was kinda an accident XD
Edit: Oh (in relation to bars 4+5)…yeah i got a bit mixed up at the start…i originally started with a few flats but then i changed it after (it then copied over…)…and since the other part was already done i forgot about it…whoops…

Fixed:
Technicality

There’s a lot of unpleasantness still in 4+5.

Take the first measure for example.

Your long notes in the bass are F, but the melody begins with E.
The interval between them is a second. Seconds are always kind of unpleasant, especially when you have them for as long as you did.
For the bass, I would have chosen an E, to match up with the melody’s E.

In the second measure, you did the opposite, the melody was playing an F, the bass was playing an E.
Again I would change the bass to an F to match up with the melody’s F.

Just wondering, did you use chords? Because they help a lot to make everything match up.